Data 9Z05 Main


Notrump vs. 4-4 Minor


 by Richard Pavlicek

Choice of Partscore

Found 40 comparisons in 40,069 deals from 72 major events 1996-2014.
First and last, and all swings of 5+ IMPs in between, are shown here.
Deals are rotated as needed to align comparison criteria to N-S.


1. 2014 USBC Final, Seg 4, Bd 56 West
Greco

Pass
Pass

Lead
D 10
C 4
C K
C Q
C 5
D A
D Q
H 5
D J
S 10
North
Levin

1 S
Pass

2nd
6
2
J
H 4
D 5
4
9
A
S 3
East
Hampson

Pass
Pass

3rd
8
A
3
8
9
7
S 2
J
H Q
South
Weinstein
Pass
1 NT


4th
K
7
10
6
H 6
3
H 2
3
2
West
Meckstroth

Pass
Pass

Lead
C J
S 5
C 6
S 4
H 5
C 10
H K
D 7
H 8
North
Moss

1 S
2 C

2nd
3
7
A
Q
A
Q
3
3
10
East
Rodwell

Pass
All Pass

3rd
2
6
7
C 8
J
D 5
7
A
C 5
South
Bathurst
Pass
1 NT


4th
K
9
4
10
2
9
6
4
S deals
None vul
S J 5 4 3 2
H K J
D 7 6
C A K Q 5
S 10 9 8
H A 10 6
D J 10 9 4
C 10 6 2
Table S A K Q 7
H Q 4 3 2
D 8 5 3
C J 7
8878A =
55553 =
Par NS +130
S 6
H 9 8 7 5
D A K Q 2
C 9 8 4 3

Notrump
1 NT South =
+90 0

  4-4 Minor
  2 C North +1
  +110 +11


4. 2013 BB Qual, Rd 18, Bd 26 West
Teramoto

Pass


Lead
H 6
D 9
H 10
D A
H K
H 2
H 8
S 10
C J
C 9
North
Thoma

Pass


2nd
9
Q
3
S 2
4
7
S 4
6
5
6
East
Ino

Pass


3rd
Q
5
5
6
C 2
S 3
C 8
K
4
Q
South
Brenner
1 NT



4th
A
2
J
3
S 7
D 10
D 4
8
3
10
West
Villas-Boas

Pass
Dbl

Lead
D Q
S 2
C J
H 5
S Q
S 9
C 8
C A
H A
H J
North
Takayama

Pass
2 D

2nd
5
3
6
K
5
10
5
10
4
6
East
Campos

Dbl
Dbl

3rd
2
K
4
8
4
J
Q
K
9
S 6
South
Kaku
1 D
1 H
All Pass

4th
4
8
2
3
7
A
3
D 7
Q
D 3
S deals
Both vul
S J 6 4 3
H 9 3
D J 8 6 5
C 10 3 2
S 10 5 2
H 10 8 7 6 4
D Q
C A Q 7 4
Table S A K 7
H Q 5
D K 10 3 2
C K J 9 8
55563 =
87869 =
Par EW +120
S Q 9 8
H A K J 2
D A 9 7 4
C 6 5

Notrump
1 NT South -3
-300 +57

  4-4 Minor
  2 D× South -2
  -500 1


7. 2013 Spingold Rd of 16, Seg 4, Bd 58 West
Lev

Pass
Pass

Lead
S 3
S K
C 3
D 7
D A
D 2
D Q
S A
S 8
H 9
North
Hampson
1 D
1 S
Pass

2nd
2
10
7
4
6
H 10
H 4
4
C 8
J
East
Hamman
Pass
Pass
Pass

3rd
Q
5
9
K
10
J
3
H 2
H 5
A
South
Greco
1 H
1 NT


4th
7
6
K
8
5
9
H 3
9
J
6
West
Platnick

Pass
Pass

Lead
D 4
S 2
C J
S A
S 6
H 2
D 5
S 8
C 7
North
Cohler
1 D
1 S
Pass

2nd
2
Q
2
4
K
10
3
H 4
9
East
Diamond
Pass
Pass
Pass

3rd
8
7
5
10
D A
Q
6
D K
4
South
CohenB
1 H
2 D


4th
10
5
K
3
9
A
7
J
N deals
Both vul
S A 8 6 2
H Q J
D Q J 10 7
C K 6 4
S J 9 5 3
H K 10 9 3
D 8 6
C A 9 5
Table S K Q 4
H A 8 4
D 9 5 4
C J 10 8 3
55585 55586
78857 =
Par EW +110
S 10 7
H 7 6 5 2
D A K 3 2
C Q 7 2

Notrump
1 NT South -1
-100 7

  4-4 Minor
  2 D North =
  +90 +57


13. 2012 Spingold Qtrfinal, Seg 1, Bd 10 West
Levin
Pass
Pass
Pass

Lead
C Q
H 2
C J
C 7
H 9
S J
H 7
S 10
North
Drijver
1 C
1 H
Pass

2nd
2
4
S 3
S 5
5
A
C 6
4
East
Weinstein
Pass
Pass
Pass

3rd
5
J
10
4
3
6
8
8
South
Brink
1 D
1 NT


4th
A
A
3
K
10
7
K
K
West
Bathurst
Pass
Pass
Pass

Lead
H A
H 5
H 4
C 8
D 10
D 2
North
Katz
1 D
1 NT
2 D

2nd
2
3
J
A
3
C 5
East
Zagorin
Pass
Pass
All Pass

3rd
6
K
D 4
4
A
6
South
Nickell
1 H
2 C


4th
7
9
8
3
Q
J
W deals
Both vul
S A 9 4
H J 9 7
D A 9 5 2
C K 3 2
S J 10 2
H K 10 6 4
D K J 3
C Q 10 4
Table S Q 8 6
H A 5
D Q 4
C J 9 8 7 6 5
67785 =
76558 66558
Par NS +90
S K 7 5 3
H Q 8 3 2
D 10 8 7 6
C A

Notrump
1 NT South -1
-100 10

  4-4 Minor
  2 D North =
  +90 +514


15. 2011 BB Semifinal, Seg 6, Bd 93 West
Drijver

Pass
Pass

Lead
S 4
D Q
H Q
D 10
D 8
H J
D 6
S 6
H 2
North
Madala

1 D
Pass

2nd
2
A
A
J
H 3
D 7
4
9
East
Brink

Pass
Pass

3rd
Q
3
6
K
5
10
C 2
10
South
Bocchi
1 C
1 NT


4th
K
2
8
C 4
9
K
S 5
J
West
Lauria

Dbl
Pass

Lead
S 5
S Q
H 8
H K
C 8
C 2
S J
C 5
D 2
H Q
North
Verhees

Rdbl
2 D

2nd
2
K
2
6
3
Q
7
7
K
5
East
Versace

1 NT
All Pass

3rd
A
4
A
S 10
A
10
9
D 6
A
9
South
v.Prooijen
1 D
2 C


4th
3
6
4
3
4
9
D 7
D 9
3
D 8
S deals
Both vul
S 7 6 2
H A K 7 5
D 10 6 5 3
C 10 8
S J 8 5 4
H Q 10 3 2
D A
C K Q 7 4
Table S A Q 9
H J 9 6 4
D J 9 4 2
C 9 3
65587 =
77856 78856
Par EW +110
S K 10 3
H 8
D K Q 8 7
C A J 6 5 2

Notrump
1 NT South -1
-100 10

  4-4 Minor
  2 D South =
  +90 +523


18. 2010 Rosenblum Semifinal, Seg 3, Bd 39 West
Hampson

Pass



Lead
H Q
H J
H 4
H A
C 6
S K
C 8
C 3
D 9
North
Fantoni

Pass



2nd
5
7
8
D 7
4
A
5
10
2
East
Greco

Pass



3rd
3
K
10
S 9
J
4
Q
2
5
South
Nunes
1 NT




4th
2
6
D 6
9
K
2
9
A
J
West
Helgemo

Dbl
Pass
All Pass

Lead
C 2
S 3
S 4
C 6
S 9
D 9
C 10
D 6
North
Gitelman

1 S
2 C


2nd
4
6
7
5
H 2
2
8
3
East
Helness

Pass
Dbl


3rd
J
Q
K
Q
10
A
A
K
South
Moss
1 D
1 NT
2 D


4th
K
2
A
9
J
4
3
J
S deals
Both vul
S Q J 5 4
H 7 5
D 9 8 7 6
C A 5 4
S A 10 8 6
H A Q J 10
D J 4
C 8 6 2
Table S 9 7 2
H K 4 3
D Q 3 2
C Q J 7 3
67697 =
66646 =
Par NS +110
S K 3
H 9 8 6 2
D A K 10 5
C K 10 9

Notrump
1 NT South -1
-100 11

  4-4 Minor
  2 D South =
  +90 +528


23. 2010 Vanderbilt Qtrfinal, Seg 4, Bd 63 West
Krekorian

Dbl


Lead
D Q
D K
S 8
D 4
C 5
C J
D 3
S J
North
BessisM
Pass
Pass


2nd
2
5
9
A
2
Q
10
East
Casen
Pass
Pass


3rd
J
S 7
2
6
K
3
S 3
South
BessisT
1 NT
Pass


4th
7
8
A
S 4
A
7
9
West
Helness

Dbl
Dbl

Lead
D A
D Q
D K
D 3
H 6
H Q
H 4
S A
S K
S 10
North
Sadek
Pass
Pass
All Pass

2nd
2
5
6
10
K
8
9
5
8
H 7
East
Helgemo
Pass
Pass


3rd
J
S 2
S 3
C 7
A
2
10
9
J
C 2
South
El Ahmady
1 NT
2 C


4th
9
4
7
8
3
5
C 8
4
6
N deals
N-S vul
S J 9
H 9 8 3
D 10 6 5 2
C 9 4 3 2
S 8 5
H A Q 7 4
D A K Q 3
C Q 6 5
Table S Q 7 6 4 3 2
H J 10 6 2
D J
C K 7
43346 =
99997 =
Par EW +400
S A K 10
H K 5
D 9 8 7 4
C A J 10 8

Notrump
1 NT× South =
+180 +1223

  4-4 Minor
  2 C× South -2
  -500 28


25. 2009 USBC Rd of 32B, Seg 1, Bd 6 West
Levin

1 H
Pass

Lead
S K
S 3
H 9
S 6
H 4
D 5
S 9
North
Rogoff
Pass
Dbl
Pass

2nd
2
Q
2
7
A
8
East
Weinstein
Pass
Pass
Pass

3rd
4
A
J
10
6
10
South
Parker
1 D
1 NT


4th
5
C 3
7
C 5
8
A
West
Simson

1 H
Pass

Lead
H 3
D 5
S 4
S 3
C 5
S 6
C Q
D 3
D Q
North
Grue
Pass
Dbl
Pass

2nd
7
4
5
7
10
8
K
2
H 5
East
Johnson
Pass
Rdbl
Pass

3rd
9
10
K
9
4
10
A
K
S Q
South
Cheek
1 D
2 C


4th
Q
A
2
C 3
2
C 7
9
8
6
N deals
N-S vul
S Q 8 7 2
H 10 8 7
D 10 3
C A 8 6 4
S K J 6 3
H K J 6 5 3
D 8 4
C K 10
Table S A 10 9 4
H 9 4
D A 7 6 2
C J 9 2
33468 33478
7A955 =
Par EW +420
S 5
H A Q 2
D K Q J 9 5
C Q 7 5 3

Notrump
1 NT South -3
-300 24

  4-4 Minor
  2 C South +1
  +110 +937


28. 2005 BB Qual, Rd 1, Bd 16 West
Madala
Pass
Pass
Pass

Lead
C J
C 2
H 8
C 4
C 10
S 4
H 9
S 7
H Q
North
Meckstroth
1 D
1 S
Pass

2nd
Q
7
K
D 6
S 2
A
2
3
A
East
Lambardi
Pass
Pass
Pass

3rd
A
9
4
5
8
5
6
Q
D 4
South
Rodwell
1 H
1 NT


4th
6
K
3
3
D 3
10
J
K
D 2
West
Freeman
Pass
Pass
Pass

Lead
D 2
H 9
H 2
C J
C 2
D 4
H Q
S A
S 2
H 6
North
Mooney
1 D
1 S
Pass

2nd
3
K
5
Q
7
10
7
9
Q
A
East
Nickell
Pass
Pass
Pass

3rd
J
4
J
A
9
A
D 9
10
K
D 7
South
Monsegur
1 H
2 D


4th
Q
3
8
6
K
C 5
S 5
4
7
C 4
W deals
E-W vul
S A 6 3 2
H 9 8
D Q 9 7 4
C K Q 3
S J 8 7 4
H A J 7 3
D J
C J 10 9 5
Table S Q 9 5
H K 2
D K 10 5 2
C A 8 4 2
65774 =
78658 =
Par EW +110
S K 10
H Q 10 6 5 4
D A 8 6 3
C 7 6

Notrump
1 NT South -2
-100 26

  4-4 Minor
  2 D North =
  +90 +543


33. 2004 Olympiad Qtrfinal, Seg 2, Bd 20 West
v.Prooijen

Pass



Lead
H 5
H J
S A
S 4
H Q
D 9
North
Carroll

Pass



2nd
2
K
5
8
C 4
A
East
Brink
Pass
Pass



3rd
A
3
2
9
8
2
South
Garvey
1 NT




4th
9
4
3
10
7
4
West
Mesbur

Pass
Pass
Dbl

Lead
C K
C A
H 5
C Q
D 9
S 5
S 4
D K
S A
North
Jansma

1 D
1 S
2 C

2nd
2
6
2
7
J
7
K
6
8
East
Fitzgibbon
Pass
Pass
Pass
Dbl

3rd
3
J
A
H 3
Q
10
2
3
9
South
Verhees
1 C
1 H
1 NT
All Pass

4th
4
5
9
8
4
Q
3
A
J
E deals
Both vul
S 9 7 2
H 7 4 2
D 7 6 4
C 10 8 6 2
S K 8 5
H 10 8 6 5 3
D K Q 2
C A K
Table S J 10 3
H A Q J
D 10 9 8 3
C Q J 3
35335 =
98AA8 =
Par EW +620
S A Q 6 4
H K 9
D A J 5
C 9 7 5 4

Notrump
1 NT South -4
-400 30

  4-4 Minor
  2 C× South -1
  -200 +548


39. 1999 USBC Semifinal, Seg 4, Bd 59 West
Stewart

Dbl


Lead
C A
H 4
S Q
S 3
D A
D K
D 3
North
Martel

Pass


2nd
2
J
K
4
6
J
H 6
East
Woolsey
Pass
Pass


3rd
7
Q
A
10
4
5
Q
South
Stansby
1 NT
Pass


4th
5
K
2
7
2
7
9
West
Silverman

Dbl
Pass

Lead
D J
S Q
S 3
D 3
D Q
S J
North
Becker

2 D


2nd
4
K
4
6
9
5
East
Wolfson
Pass
Pass


3rd
2
A
10
10
8
H 3
South
Kamil
1 D
Pass


4th
A
2
7
7
C 9
9
E deals
None vul
S A J 8 3
H J 10 2
D Q 10 5 4
C 6 2
S K 9 7
H A 6 4
D J 6
C A K 10 9 3
Table S 6 5 4 2
H Q 9 7
D 9 7 2
C Q 7 4
789A7 =
54436 =
Par NS +140
S Q 10
H K 8 5 3
D A K 8 3
C J 8 5

Notrump
1 NT× South +2
+380 +641

  4-4 Minor
  2 D South +2
  +130 49


40. 1998 USBC Semifinal, Seg 3, Bd 43 West
Kamil

Dbl
Pass

Lead
H 3
S 9
C K
S 2
H 10
S Q
North
Rodwell
Pass
1 H
Pass

2nd
5
A
A
6
Q
7
East
Becker
Pass
Pass
Pass

3rd
K
5
9
K
A
10
South
Meckstroth
1 D
1 NT


4th
2
3
5
D 8
8
C 3
West
Soloway

Dbl
Pass

Lead
S Q
H Q
D 2
H 2
D 3
North
Stansby
Pass
2 D


2nd
3
3
8
6
Q
East
Hamman
Pass
Pass


3rd
9
5
5
8
S 4
South
Martel
1 D
Pass


4th
A
K
4
10
7
N deals
None vul
S 8 7 6 3
H 8 5
D A K 7 4
C 10 9 7
S Q J 5 4 2
H A 9 6 3
D 5
C A 4 2
Table S K 10 9
H K 10 4
D 9 6 3 2
C J 6 5
65698 =
58635 58645
Par NS +100
S A
H Q J 7 2
D Q J 10 8
C K Q 8 3

Notrump
1 NT South -1
-50 41

  4-4 Minor
  2 D South =
  +90 +453


Data 9Z05 MainTop Notrump vs. 4-4 Minor

© 2014 Richard Pavlicek