Quiz 8D71 Main


Plus or Fishfood


 by Richard Pavlicek

Welcome to bridge purgatory. Face masks are required, not for health reasons but to avoid being recognized for your past bridge mistakes. This may be the turning point of your life! Either straighten up and return to the bridge world, or transcend to the other side. Don’t worry; there is life on the other side, but you won’t be allowed to touch a deck of cards ever.

As South, you will declare 6 NT four times. But wait! Scoring is not the usual IMPs or matchpoints, or even total points. This will be the ultimate make-it-or-else scoring, called plus or fishfood. Either guarantee a plus score, or you’ll go swimming — in a tank filled with piranha! And those little buggers are hungry. Trust me! I’ve already lost two fingers just preparing this page.

Choose your play on each problem then click “Score Me” to see how you did. Following the quiz are explanations from the six survivors. That’s right; only six made it out so far. Good luck — or stick around for dinner!

Problem 1

Plus-or-fishfoodS 2WestNorthEastSouth
None vulH Q 10 8 41 DPass1 S
D A K Q 10 8 3Pass2 HPass3 C
C K QPass3 DPass5 NT1
Table Pass6 CPass6 NT2
Lead: C 3East plays C 2 All Pass
 
 1. pick a slam
S A K 10 9 8 72. but not 6 C!
H A J
D 2
6 NT SouthC A J 5 4You win the C K

What next? A. Finesse the S 10
B. Finesse the H J
C. Win D A-K-Q
D. Win C Q, finesse S 10
E.  Win C Q, H A, lead H J
F.  Win C Q, finesse H J

Problem 2

Plus-or-fishfoodS 4 3WestNorthEastSouth
N-S vulH A K 10Pass1 D
D 6 5 4 2Pass1 H1Pass2 S
C A Q 5 4Pass3 DPass3 NT
Table Pass5 NT2Pass6 NT
Lead: H 9 All Pass
 
 1. eccentric but sensible
S A K Q 22. pick a slam
H J
D A K Q 3
6 NT SouthC K 6 3 2If you play diamonds, East follows once then pitches a heart

Your play? A. Win H A, S A-K-Q (all follow), lead S 2
B. Win H A, duck a spade
C. Win H A, D A-K-Q, lead D 3
D. Win H A, D A-K, lead D 3
E.  Win H A, D A-K, C K, C A
F.  Finesse the H 10

Quit

Top Plus or Fishfood

Problem 3

Plus-or-fishfoodS 6 5 4 3WestNorthEastSouth
E-W vulH 5 4 32 C
D K QPass2 DPass2 NT
C K Q 10 9Pass3 CPass3 D
Table Pass5 NTPass6 NT
Lead: S JEast plays S 8 All Pass
 
 
S A K Q
H A K
D A 4 3 2
6 NT SouthC A 5 4 3You win the S A, as the piranha swirl… they smell flesh!

What next? A. Win S K-Q, D K-Q, H A, D A
B. Win S K-Q, D K-Q, H A, lead D 4
C. Win D K-Q, S K, D A
D. Win D K-Q, S K, lead D 4
E.  Win D K-Q, H A, D A
F.  Win D K-Q, H A, lead D 4

Problem 4

Plus-or-fishfoodS A K 7 6 5WestNorthEastSouth
Both vulH Q 3Pass1 SPass2 NT
D A JPass3 CPass3 H
C A Q 3 2Pass5 NT1Pass6 NT2
Table PassPassPass
Lead: C JEast plays C 8 
 1. Why all the 5 NT bids?
 2. We know this will be the contract
S Q 2
H A K 10 9
D K 8 3
6 NT SouthC K 6 5 4Last chance to avoid a dunking!

Your play? A. Win C A, S Q, duck a spade
B. Win C A, S Q, run H 10
C. Win C A, lead H 3 to 10
D. Win C A-Q, S A, S Q
E.  Win C A-Q, S Q, S A
F.  Win C A, S Q, finesse D J

Quit

Explanations

Top Plus or Fishfood

Problem 1

Plus-or-fishfoodS 2TrickLead2nd3rd4th
Both vulH Q 10 8 41. WC 3K24
D A K Q 10 8 32. NH 4!5J!K
C K Q3. WD 4A52
S Q J 6 4 3 TableS 54. NH 86A2
H K 3 2H 9 7 6 55. SC 56Q7
D 4D J 9 7 6 5Win the rest
C 10 8 6 3C 9 7 2
S A K 10 9 8 7
H A J
D 2
6 NT SouthC A J 5 4

Nicholas Greer: Finesse the H J at trick two. If it loses, I have two spades, three hearts, three diamonds and four clubs, and can untangle them on any return. If the H J wins, cash the H A, cross to dummy with a second club and lead the H Q; again, opponents cannot tangle my entries.

Wojciech Papuga: Take the heart finesse. Playing H A, H J is no good, because a spade switch now ruins the communication.

Problem 2

Plus-or-fishfoodS 4 3TrickLead2nd3rd4th
Both vulH A K 101. WH 910!QJ
D 6 5 4 22. EH 2C 2!6A
C A Q 5 43. ND 210A7
S J 9 8 7 TableS 10 6 54. SD K84H 3
H 9 8 7 6H Q 5 4 3 25. SC K1047
D J 9 8 7D 106. SC 3H 7A8
C 10C J 9 8 77. ND 5H 4Q9
S A K Q 28. SC 6H 8Q9
H J9. NH K5D 3?
D A K Q 3West is squeezed
6 NT SouthC K 6 3 2

Grant Peacock: Duck the heart (queen wins). On any return (if a heart pitch a club) win S A, C A-K and D A-K. If one defender guards both minors, win S K-Q (pitch diamond), C Q and finish hearts pitching a spade. If each defender guards one minor, win D Q, C Q and finish hearts pitching a diamond.

Sherman Yuen: Duck the first trick, then win S A, D A-K, C K-A and H A (pitch clubs). Either one of the minor suits break, or a simple squeeze in the minors, or a double squeeze with spades as the common suit.

Quiz 8D71 MainTop Plus or Fishfood

Problem 3

Plus-or-fishfoodS 6 5 4 3TrickLead2nd3rd4th
Both vulH 5 4 31. WS J38A
D K Q2. SD 2!7K5
C K Q 10 93. ND Q638
S J 10 TableS 9 8 7 24. NS 42K10
H Q 10 9 8 6 2H J 75. SD 4!9H 310
D J 9 8 7D 10 6 56. EH 7A24
C 2C J 8 7 67. SS QH 657
S A K Q8. SD A!JH 5H J
H A K9. SH K8S 6S 9
D A 4 3 210. SC 32K8
6 NT SouthC A 5 4 311. NC Q!
Win the rest

Nick Jacob: Win S Q, D K-Q and S K, then lose a diamond (pitch heart). Win H A, D A (pitch heart), S A, and finally H K throwing spade if not yet good. This will yield a count to reveal one defender who cannot hold four clubs.

Nicholas Greer: Unblock diamonds, return to hand in spades, then duck a diamond throwing a heart. If a diamond comes back, throw another heart. Now cash spade, D A and remaining heart(s) discarding a spade if it isn’t good. Now only one opponent can guard clubs. Important to cash D A before the last heart.

Nicholas’s last sentence is the crux of the problem. You do not want to reach this ending:

NT win 5S 6
H
D
C K Q 10 9
S  ? TableS  ?
H  ?H  ?
D  ?D  ?
C  ?C  ?
S
H
D A
South leadsC A 5 4 3

On the D A West follows with the last diamond, you pitch the spade from dummy, and East copies with the last spade. Now either defender could guard clubs, and you cannot tell which. But if South could lead the H A instead (having won the D A before) there is a lock: If East follows, he cannot guard clubs; if East pitches his spade, he must have all clubs.

While no matter at “plus or fishfood,” in actual play declarer should cash the C K (or C Q) early. This does not affect flexibility in clubs and might expose a stiff C J (or void) to ensure 12 tricks and be playing for 13 if spades break.

Problem 4

Plus-or-fishfoodS A K 7 6 5TrickLead2nd3rd4th
Both vulH Q 31. WC JQ84
D A J2. NS 5!8Q3
C A Q 3 23. SH 1043!J
S 4 3 TableS J 10 9 84. EH 2A7Q
H 8 7 4H J 6 5 25. SC 57AD 5
D 10 6 4 2D Q 9 7 56. NS A924
C J 10 9 7C 87. NS K10C 6H 8
S Q 28. NC 2H 5K9
H A K 10 99. SH KD 2S 66
D K 8 310. SH 9?
6 NT SouthC K 6 5 4West then East squeezed

Charles Blair: Win the C A, C Q, S A and S Q. [Assume a show-out in both suits, else claim.] 1. If four clubs and 5+ spades in one hand, lose a heart to partner, then a simple squeeze. 2. If West holds spades and East clubs, win the C K then lose a club [to endplay East]. 3. If West holds clubs and East spades, run the H 10, then a double squeeze after discarding a club on the S K.

Grant Peacock: Win the C A, S Q and duck a spade. After any return, win the C Q. If one defender has four clubs and 5+ spades, run hearts then diamonds to squeeze him. If the black-suit stoppers are split, cash all black-suit winners, D K and D A; then if neither the S 7 nor C 3 is good, hearts must run.

This was not a good problem, as it has multiple solutions. My plan was to win the C Q and S Q then run the H 10. When it loses, East cannot attack diamonds, so next win the H Q, S A and C A to reveal who guards clubs. Next lead the S K to reveal who (if either) can guard spades, resulting in a simple squeeze if the same defender, else a double squeeze with threats: S 7, C 3 and D 8 (common). This is 100 percent… but, so are the above.

Indeed, there’s more than one way to skin a cat.* Charles’s line is best in actual play, because it reveals a 3-2 club break immediately, then he’d be playing for seven at no risk; whereas my line may lose a trick unnecessarily, and Grant’s line always loses a trick.

*Um… as for skinning cats, I’d be afraid of a guy who knows even one way.

Nick Jacob Wins

This contest ran from January 23 to February 22, 2021. There were 21 entries from 13 persons (multiple entries were allowed but only the latest one counted) of which only six were correct on all four problems. Too bad about the other seven; not only for their sake but for mine, as the filtration system of my aquarium is clogged with flesh. C’est la vie — just another reminder that there’s more to life than a free lunch.

Congratulations to Nick Jacob, who was first of the six survivors, ranked below by date-time of entry. Nick is only a recent participant, with several other high placings before this first win.

Survivor List
RankNameLocation
1Nick JacobNew Zealand
2Nicholas GreerEngland
3Grant PeacockMaryland
4Wojciech PapugaPoland
5Charles BlairIllinois
6Sherman YuenSingapore

Predictably, the locations of the top four survivors all end in “Land.”
The secret to avoid being fishfood of course is to stay on land!

Last gasps

Sherman Yuen: On Problem 1 it felt like the spot cards were the fishfood.
Or were they dried smoked fish? Either way, I hope they weren’t your fingers!

Charles Blair: The Game is Afootagain!

Ah, he remembers, but the piranha are meaner now after 18 years in captivity.

Grant Peacock: At this form of scoring I would bid every hand to one notrump, not six.

Nick Jacob: Does the 250-character limit refer to the number of piranha in the tank?

No, the number of victims. So far I’ve tossed 247 characters (would-be bridge players) into the tank.
Three more is the limit. Will I retire then? Nope… I’ll buy another tank.

Quiz 8D71 MainTop Plus or Fishfood

© 2018 Richard Pavlicek